Whether you’re currently interviewing for a job without benefits or want to learn more before applying, ask yourself: What should I consider before accepting a job with no benefits?
These insights from experts will help you weigh your options to decide if taking a job without benefits is suitable for your career and financial situation.
But first: Here’s why employee benefits matter so much.
How Important Are Job Benefits?
To help you understand the value of employer-provided benefits, a federal employment survey found that benefits account for approximately 30% of an employer’s total compensation costs. Specifically, only two-thirds of total compensation comes in the form of base salary. This makes benefits a major incentive for employees and a significant cost for employers.
So, what exactly are job benefits? They typically include health insurance, 401(k) plans or other retirement savings programs, and paid time off (PTO). Companies may also offer additional perks such as free office meals, mental health days, or on-site childcare—benefits that can have a surprisingly large impact on your decision to accept a job without benefits.
In some cases—for example, if you’re job hunting during an economic recession—benefits may not be available. Regardless of whether the lack of benefits stems from economic conditions or other factors, it’s crucial to assess your financial situation before deciding whether to accept a job with no benefits.
How Will Accepting a Job Without Benefits Affect My Finances?
Tim Jordan, a certified financial coach, says that to determine the financial impact of taking a job without benefits, it helps to create a budget based on your current job.
Your budget will help you crunch the numbers and see if accepting the job without benefits is a wise choice. Jordan notes that if you move from a job with benefits to one without, you might find that a higher salary doesn’t result in a net financial gain once you factor in the extra costs previously covered by benefits.
If you accept the job without benefits, you’ll be responsible for paying for your own insurance, contributing to retirement savings, and budgeting for unpaid time off. An updated budget will make it easier to manage these new expenses.
Ashley Patrick, another financial coach, advises: “Rules of thumb aren’t precise enough to figure out how these expenses will fit into your budget. You need actual numbers.”
Below are the biggest expenses you’ll need to calculate if you take a job without benefits:
- You’ll pay for your own medical insuranceHealth insurance costs can vary greatly depending on the plan you choose. That’s why Patrick suggests writing down your specific health needs before getting quotes from potential insurers.
Do you take prescription medications? Do you require specialized treatment for a medical condition? Your answers to these questions will influence the type of health insurance plan you select. From plan types to coverage levels, you have many options—your goal is to ensure your needs are met without paying for unnecessary coverage.
For health and dental insurance, Jordan recommends checking your state’s insurance marketplace to estimate monthly premiums that match your medical needs.
Jordan adds: “If you want to keep health, dental, and vision insurance bundled together, contacting an insurance broker will be your best bet.”
He suggests gathering 3 to 5 health insurance quotes. From there, you can add the monthly premium cost to your budget and estimate how your new insurance will affect your current medical spending (e.g., on medications and doctor’s visits).
- You’re responsible for keeping your retirement savings on trackJordan emphasizes that even without an employer-sponsored retirement plan, you should still save for retirement using an Individual Retirement Account (IRA).
“The opportunity cost of not investing is too high,” he says. “I strongly recommend investing in a Roth IRA or Traditional IRA to keep growing your money. Start with the same percentage of your income you’re currently investing and add that to your list of monthly expenses.”
If you were previously investing more than the annual IRA contribution limit (set by the government at $7,000 to $8,000 per year), Jordan suggests investing the difference in low-cost index funds that track the performance of the broader market. While this money won’t qualify for the same tax advantages, your retirement savings will still grow over time.
If your current employer matches a percentage of your retirement contributions, calculate that amount to better understand your potential financial loss, Jordan advises. While this will lower your future retirement savings rate, it won’t necessarily affect your budget—unless you choose to replace the lost match with money from your salary.
The bottom line: Whether you receive benefits through work or not, prioritize retirement savings. If you need tips to get started, here’s how to create a retirement budget.
- You won’t have paid vacation daysJordan notes that without paid time off, you’ll likely take fewer days off. But he warns against pushing through without planning for vacation or sick days, as this can quickly lead to burnout.
Do the math: Use an online paycheck calculator to get a close estimate of your biweekly take-home pay after taxes and withholdings (e.g., for Social Security and Medicare). Divide that amount by 10 to calculate your daily earnings at the potential new job, Jordan says. Then multiply that daily rate by the number of days you expect to take off.
This will give you the total cost of your unpaid time off. To determine how much to set aside monthly for this expense, simply divide the total by 12. Once this amount is included in your budget, you’ll have a realistic understanding of the impact—and you’ll be able to afford a well-deserved break if you accept the job without benefits.
How Can I Calculate If a Job Without Benefits Is a Good Offer?
Now that you’ve identified the extra expenses to include in your budget, the next step is to determine if the offer is actually good for you.
Jordan recommends using a paycheck calculator to find your monthly income after state and federal taxes. Then, subtract your new monthly expenses (for medical insurance, retirement savings, and vacation) to get your “real” take-home pay. Finally, compare this figure to your current monthly salary using your latest paychecks. Side-by-side comparison of these numbers will bring you closer to a decision.
When Should I Reject a Job Without Benefits?
After calculating your post-tax, post-expense income at the new job and comparing it to your current salary, Jordan says you should ask yourself two questions: “Does the new salary cover your new expenses and still leave you with enough to live comfortably? Will you have more cash flow—or less—than you do now?”
If the new job (without benefits) puts you in the same or a better financial position, you may want to seriously consider accepting the offer. However, if the financial loss outweighs the gain, your next step should be to negotiate.
What Are Some Tips for Negotiating Salary for a Job Without Benefits?
Patrick advises not to hesitate to negotiate a higher starting salary to compensate for the lack of benefits after receiving an offer for a full-time job with no benefits. “It doesn’t hurt to ask—the worst they can say is no,” she says.
Below are tips for negotiating higher pay for a job without benefits:
- Tell your potential employer your current total compensation (including all benefits) and how much it will cost you to replace those benefits each month, Jordan says. Then say: “Based on these amounts, I’ll need an annual salary of $X. Is that possible?”
- If a salary increase isn’t an option, ask for non-salary benefits such as a health insurance stipend; reimbursements for childcare, tuition, or housing; moving expenses; flexible work hours; additional paid time off; or funding for professional development opportunities, Patrick suggests.
It will likely be harder to negotiate a raise or additional benefits after you start the job, so follow Patrick’s advice and negotiate before accepting the offer.
How Do I Financially Prepare After Accepting a Job Without Benefits?
If you decide to take the job without benefits, you’ll have to manage your own benefits. Patrick calls this “the awareness bump”—you’re responsible for not only budgeting for these expenses but also setting up essential services (like health insurance) and paying for them on time each month.
After setting up your self-funded benefits, Patrick recommends two key steps to replicate the experience of having a job with benefits:
- Create separate accounts for key expensesOpen a dedicated savings or checking account for each major expense (e.g., one account specifically for monthly insurance premiums). Multiple accounts will help you manage these costs and ensure you always have enough money set aside.
- Automate payments and savingsWith a job that offers benefits, you don’t have to do much to fund those perks. Mimic this by setting up automatic payments—such as monthly contributions to an IRA—to ensure your money goes where it needs to.
Be Sure to Choose What’s Right for You
Are you still asking: “Should I take a job without benefits?” If you follow these steps, you’ll have a clear understanding of the financial pros and cons of the offer, tailored to your unique situation.
At the end of the day, your job isn’t just about money, Patrick says. While you want to ensure the offer is financially viable, that’s not the only factor to consider.
Jordan adds: “A job without benefits isn’t automatically a bad financial decision. If your current job makes you unhappy, or if an opportunity aligns with your life’s purpose comes along, benefits may matter less.”
By carefully weighing your options and considering your unique circumstances, you’ll be able to decide if a job without benefits is right for you—both professionally and financially. If you decide to take the leap, here’s how to financially prepare for a career transition.
Home
detail
Accepting a Job Without Benefits: What You Need to Know
2025-10-16T18:50:18
Whether you’re currently interviewing for a job without benefits or want to learn more before applying, ask yourself: What should I consider before accepting a job with no benefits?
These insights from experts will help you weigh your options to decide if taking a job without benefits is suitable for your career and financial situation.
But first: Here’s why employee benefits matter so much.
How Important Are Job Benefits?
To help you understand the value of employer-provided benefits, a federal employment survey found that benefits account for approximately 30% of an employer’s total compensation costs. Specifically, only two-thirds of total compensation comes in the form of base salary. This makes benefits a major incentive for employees and a significant cost for employers.
So, what exactly are job benefits? They typically include health insurance, 401(k) plans or other retirement savings programs, and paid time off (PTO). Companies may also offer additional perks such as free office meals, mental health days, or on-site childcare—benefits that can have a surprisingly large impact on your decision to accept a job without benefits.
In some cases—for example, if you’re job hunting during an economic recession—benefits may not be available. Regardless of whether the lack of benefits stems from economic conditions or other factors, it’s crucial to assess your financial situation before deciding whether to accept a job with no benefits.
How Will Accepting a Job Without Benefits Affect My Finances?
Tim Jordan, a certified financial coach, says that to determine the financial impact of taking a job without benefits, it helps to create a budget based on your current job.
Your budget will help you crunch the numbers and see if accepting the job without benefits is a wise choice. Jordan notes that if you move from a job with benefits to one without, you might find that a higher salary doesn’t result in a net financial gain once you factor in the extra costs previously covered by benefits.
If you accept the job without benefits, you’ll be responsible for paying for your own insurance, contributing to retirement savings, and budgeting for unpaid time off. An updated budget will make it easier to manage these new expenses.
Ashley Patrick, another financial coach, advises: “Rules of thumb aren’t precise enough to figure out how these expenses will fit into your budget. You need actual numbers.”
Below are the biggest expenses you’ll need to calculate if you take a job without benefits:
- You’ll pay for your own medical insuranceHealth insurance costs can vary greatly depending on the plan you choose. That’s why Patrick suggests writing down your specific health needs before getting quotes from potential insurers.
Do you take prescription medications? Do you require specialized treatment for a medical condition? Your answers to these questions will influence the type of health insurance plan you select. From plan types to coverage levels, you have many options—your goal is to ensure your needs are met without paying for unnecessary coverage.
For health and dental insurance, Jordan recommends checking your state’s insurance marketplace to estimate monthly premiums that match your medical needs.
Jordan adds: “If you want to keep health, dental, and vision insurance bundled together, contacting an insurance broker will be your best bet.”
He suggests gathering 3 to 5 health insurance quotes. From there, you can add the monthly premium cost to your budget and estimate how your new insurance will affect your current medical spending (e.g., on medications and doctor’s visits).
- You’re responsible for keeping your retirement savings on trackJordan emphasizes that even without an employer-sponsored retirement plan, you should still save for retirement using an Individual Retirement Account (IRA).
“The opportunity cost of not investing is too high,” he says. “I strongly recommend investing in a Roth IRA or Traditional IRA to keep growing your money. Start with the same percentage of your income you’re currently investing and add that to your list of monthly expenses.”
If you were previously investing more than the annual IRA contribution limit (set by the government at $7,000 to $8,000 per year), Jordan suggests investing the difference in low-cost index funds that track the performance of the broader market. While this money won’t qualify for the same tax advantages, your retirement savings will still grow over time.
If your current employer matches a percentage of your retirement contributions, calculate that amount to better understand your potential financial loss, Jordan advises. While this will lower your future retirement savings rate, it won’t necessarily affect your budget—unless you choose to replace the lost match with money from your salary.
The bottom line: Whether you receive benefits through work or not, prioritize retirement savings. If you need tips to get started, here’s how to create a retirement budget.
- You won’t have paid vacation daysJordan notes that without paid time off, you’ll likely take fewer days off. But he warns against pushing through without planning for vacation or sick days, as this can quickly lead to burnout.
Do the math: Use an online paycheck calculator to get a close estimate of your biweekly take-home pay after taxes and withholdings (e.g., for Social Security and Medicare). Divide that amount by 10 to calculate your daily earnings at the potential new job, Jordan says. Then multiply that daily rate by the number of days you expect to take off.
This will give you the total cost of your unpaid time off. To determine how much to set aside monthly for this expense, simply divide the total by 12. Once this amount is included in your budget, you’ll have a realistic understanding of the impact—and you’ll be able to afford a well-deserved break if you accept the job without benefits.
How Can I Calculate If a Job Without Benefits Is a Good Offer?
Now that you’ve identified the extra expenses to include in your budget, the next step is to determine if the offer is actually good for you.
Jordan recommends using a paycheck calculator to find your monthly income after state and federal taxes. Then, subtract your new monthly expenses (for medical insurance, retirement savings, and vacation) to get your “real” take-home pay. Finally, compare this figure to your current monthly salary using your latest paychecks. Side-by-side comparison of these numbers will bring you closer to a decision.
When Should I Reject a Job Without Benefits?
After calculating your post-tax, post-expense income at the new job and comparing it to your current salary, Jordan says you should ask yourself two questions: “Does the new salary cover your new expenses and still leave you with enough to live comfortably? Will you have more cash flow—or less—than you do now?”
If the new job (without benefits) puts you in the same or a better financial position, you may want to seriously consider accepting the offer. However, if the financial loss outweighs the gain, your next step should be to negotiate.
What Are Some Tips for Negotiating Salary for a Job Without Benefits?
Patrick advises not to hesitate to negotiate a higher starting salary to compensate for the lack of benefits after receiving an offer for a full-time job with no benefits. “It doesn’t hurt to ask—the worst they can say is no,” she says.
Below are tips for negotiating higher pay for a job without benefits:
- Tell your potential employer your current total compensation (including all benefits) and how much it will cost you to replace those benefits each month, Jordan says. Then say: “Based on these amounts, I’ll need an annual salary of $X. Is that possible?”
- If a salary increase isn’t an option, ask for non-salary benefits such as a health insurance stipend; reimbursements for childcare, tuition, or housing; moving expenses; flexible work hours; additional paid time off; or funding for professional development opportunities, Patrick suggests.
It will likely be harder to negotiate a raise or additional benefits after you start the job, so follow Patrick’s advice and negotiate before accepting the offer.
How Do I Financially Prepare After Accepting a Job Without Benefits?
If you decide to take the job without benefits, you’ll have to manage your own benefits. Patrick calls this “the awareness bump”—you’re responsible for not only budgeting for these expenses but also setting up essential services (like health insurance) and paying for them on time each month.
After setting up your self-funded benefits, Patrick recommends two key steps to replicate the experience of having a job with benefits:
- Create separate accounts for key expensesOpen a dedicated savings or checking account for each major expense (e.g., one account specifically for monthly insurance premiums). Multiple accounts will help you manage these costs and ensure you always have enough money set aside.
- Automate payments and savingsWith a job that offers benefits, you don’t have to do much to fund those perks. Mimic this by setting up automatic payments—such as monthly contributions to an IRA—to ensure your money goes where it needs to.
Be Sure to Choose What’s Right for You
Are you still asking: “Should I take a job without benefits?” If you follow these steps, you’ll have a clear understanding of the financial pros and cons of the offer, tailored to your unique situation.
At the end of the day, your job isn’t just about money, Patrick says. While you want to ensure the offer is financially viable, that’s not the only factor to consider.
Jordan adds: “A job without benefits isn’t automatically a bad financial decision. If your current job makes you unhappy, or if an opportunity aligns with your life’s purpose comes along, benefits may matter less.”
By carefully weighing your options and considering your unique circumstances, you’ll be able to decide if a job without benefits is right for you—both professionally and financially. If you decide to take the leap, here’s how to financially prepare for a career transition.